Stellar
<- Go Back

GitHub Copilot and Claude: What You Need to Know

GitHub Copilot has been a developer's companion for a while now, with a new feature catching everyone's eye—integration with Claude, an AI model developed by Anthropic. But how does it stack up against the GitHub Copilot we're used to, and should you use GitHub Copilot with Claude? Let’s dive into it, including how this setup compares to Fine, a modern AI development platform that gives developers more power and choice.

Table of Contents

Should I Use GitHub Copilot with Claude?

For months, Claude 3.5 Sonnet has been accepted as the better LLM for coding compared to GPT-4. Using GitHub Copilot with Claude can help developers who prefer a broader context understanding when writing and optimizing code. Claude's strength lies in natural language processing and its ability to generate human-like responses, which may come in handy for devs seeking greater conversational interaction.

Claude 3.5 Sonnet, which was announced on October 29th at GitHub Universe 2024, is currently in public preview and available to all Copilot plans over a two-week rollout. Initially, Claude 3.5 Sonnet is available in Copilot Chat for Visual Studio Code and in immersive chat on the GitHub website. It excels at coding tasks across the entire software development lifecycle, from initial design to bug fixes, maintenance to optimizations.

However, there are limitations to pairing GitHub Copilot with Claude. For one, it remains just another integration in the Copilot ecosystem, subject to GitHub’s usage policies and pricing tiers. You may still find that the depth of Claude's integration within Copilot lacks the smoothness that many developers crave when switching between models or fine-tuning AI behavior.

With Fine, developers aren’t limited by these constraints. You can seamlessly switch between GPT-4o, Claude 3.5 Sonnet, and GPT o1-preview, all without extra charges. This flexibility means that you can utilize the specific strengths of each model based on the context of your coding problem—a luxury GitHub Copilot simply doesn’t provide.

Is GPT or Claude Faster in GitHub Copilot?

Speed is a key factor for developers when choosing an AI assistant. Generally, GPT-4 is a powerful and versatile model, capable of quickly producing accurate code snippets. Claude, on the other hand, tends to excel at understanding extended conversations, but it might lag slightly behind GPT in generating complex or niche code solutions due to its more conservative approach.

If you’re choosing between GPT and Claude in GitHub Copilot, your choice will depend on your needs. GPT-4 is typically faster for raw code generation, while Claude might shine in contexts where explanations or detailed discussions are needed. However, there's still some inconsistency in switching between these models while using GitHub Copilot.

Fine has managed to solve this issue elegantly. You don’t have to compromise on speed—you can switch between models fluidly, depending on your needs for coding or explaining concepts, and without facing any hidden costs. Fine empowers you to have the fastest and most relevant AI model in your toolkit whenever you need it, whereas GitHub Copilot limits you to a specific model per instance.

How to Set Up Claude in GitHub Copilot

If you’re curious about how to get started with Claude in GitHub Copilot, it’s fairly straightforward. First, ensure you have GitHub Copilot installed as an extension in your IDE, then follow these steps:

  1. Update GitHub Copilot: Check if there’s an update available that includes support for Claude 3.5 Sonnet, as this feature might be in beta or have specific requirements.
  2. Enable Claude Integration: Head into the settings of your GitHub Copilot. There, you can choose between available AI models and select Claude if it's available in your region or subscription. You may also be prompted to enable Claude 3.5 Sonnet the first time you use Copilot Chat in Visual Studio Code or in the immersive view on the GitHub website.
  3. Check Access Availability: To know if you or your organization has access to Claude 3.5 Sonnet, check the bottom of your Copilot policy settings. If there is no policy listed for Anthropic Claude 3.5 Sonnet, you have not yet received access via the rollout.
  4. Use Claude in Your Workflow: Once enabled, start coding. You’ll be able to see the suggestions from Claude, similar to those from GPT, but keep in mind that you may need a compatible tier to access this model.

Setup for organizational use involves the organization owner enabling or disabling Claude 3.5 Sonnet for all assigned Copilot Business users. See GitHub's documentation on managing policies for more details.

While this process is not overly complex, it does involve additional steps and may incur extra costs, depending on your subscription. In contrast, with Fine, you don’t need to fuss over updates, availability, or paywall restrictions—you simply switch models in real-time without worrying about fees or beta features.

Why Fine is the Better Choice for Developers

The ability to switch between AI models on the fly is crucial for a productive development experience. Fine takes the lead by providing access to multiple advanced models, including Claude 3.5 Sonnet, GPT4o, and GPT o1-preview—all without any additional cost to the user. This empowers developers to choose the best model for each specific coding task, be it raw code generation, deeper context understanding, or debugging.

Fine’s newly introduced AI Sandboxing feature also takes collaboration up a notch. It allows developers to build, run, and test AI-generated code within a secure virtual environment right in their browser. No more “works on my machine” issues—Fine ensures that all code runs smoothly across environments and is ready for review or sharing without a hitch.

In contrast, GitHub Copilot’s reliance on limited integrations and subscription-based access keeps developers boxed in. Fine’s flexibility, integrated live testing, and straightforward approach make it the standout choice for developers who want control, speed, and ease of use.

If you're a startup looking to save serious time - Fine allows you to delegate entire tasks to AI, letting your development team focus on the bigger projects.

Ready to Supercharge Your Development?

GitHub Copilot with Claude may offer an interesting blend of capabilities, but it comes with limitations, such as added costs, lack of flexibility, and complex setup processes. On the other hand, Fine provides developers with unparalleled flexibility, real-time access to multiple advanced models, and a powerful sandboxing environment—all without hidden costs or complex restrictions.

Sources

GitHub Copilot Documentation - Using Claude 3.5 Sonnet

Fine - Collaborative AI Coding Platform

GitHub Universe 2024 - Claude 3.5 Sonnet Announcement

How Fine Works

Start building today

Try out the smoothest way to build, launch and manage an app

Try for Free ->